Build, Co-Manage, or Outsource? How Community Banks Should Evaluate Managed IT
By Sean Martin
Even a strong, capable IT team can only handle so much. As responsibilities (and risk) grow, financial institution leaders need to decide where to keep investing internally and where outside expertise can help close gaps without sacrificing control.
IT Teams Are Being Asked to Cover More
For many financial institutions, the same team handling user support and system maintenance is also expected to monitor threats, manage vendors, test backups, prepare for exams, and advance other IT initiatives. Everything may seem to be working fine until someone leaves, or an after-hours emergency hits.
Hiring employees isn’t always an option. Across industries, ISACA reports that 55% of cybersecurity teams are understaffed and 65% have unfilled positions. Meanwhile, 73% of respondents to the American Bankers Association’s Community Bank CEO Priorities for 2026 survey said that cybersecurity and data breaches “keep them up at night,” with recruiting and retaining talent also ranking among their biggest growth concerns.
That changes the conversation around managed IT services. Instead of starting with, “Should we outsource IT?” ask: Where do we need more capacity, expertise, or coverage, and what’s the most practical way to get it?
Answering that question starts with a five-step review of your current needs, costs, and options.
1. Assess Your Current Gaps
Before adding another position or evaluating managed IT service providers, look at what your team is already being asked to cover and how much bandwidth and flexibility they have:
What routine tasks often get backed up?
Which responsibilities depend heavily on one person?
What happens after hours or when someone is on vacation?
Who takes over when a team member leaves or a major incident occurs?
Look across infrastructure, cybersecurity, end-user support, backup and recovery, vendor management, documentation, and technology planning. One option is to use the CIS cybersecurity framework to identify gaps through a standardized perspective.
Next, consider the consequences of each gap. A slow help desk can frustrate employees and hurt productivity. Missed patches, limited monitoring, or poor documentation can create bigger problems for security and exam readiness.
Once those gaps are clear, priorities should be set based on the most critical business needs.
2. Prioritize the Biggest Business and Risk Impacts
Rank each gap in your IT team by potential risks if your existing staff are unable to address an issue promptly.
Start with areas tied to cybersecurity, regulatory readiness, employee productivity, and account holder service. You don’t need deep internal expertise across the board, but you do need dependable coverage where a failure could disrupt operations or increase risk.
This step also helps keep technology decisions tied to your financial institution’s strategy. A gap that slows growth plans or leaves a critical system without adequate coverage should rise above work that’s simply inconvenient.
With the priorities established, you can determine what it would take to address them internally.
3. Consider the Full Cost of Building Internally
The median annual wage for an information security analyst was about $129,000 in 2025, according to the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, with employment projected to grow 29% from 2024 through 2034.
Add to that recruiting, benefits, certifications, training, security tools, licensing, after-hours coverage, and backup staffing. Specialized employees may also be difficult to replace quickly if they leave.
Outside support won’t always cost less. The goal is to compare the full cost of maintaining the same expertise, coverage, and continuity over time, whether you build those capabilities internally or bring in outside support. The cost of a security breach or systems outage resulting from poor cyber hygiene may be significantly more.
4. Match Outside Support to the Need
With that comparison in hand, decide where outside support makes sense. Managed services don’t have to be all or nothing.
A financial institution with a strong internal IT team may need help only in specific areas, such as 24/7 security monitoring, device management, or backup and recovery. In cases like this, priorities and decisions can be made internally while a partner fills defined capacity or expertise gaps.
Outside support can also free up team members from routine work so they can focus on strategic projects, vendor management, security decisions, and technology planning.
And outsourcing the work doesn’t mean outsourcing accountability. Leadership should know what’s being handled and who’s accountable. Outsourcing also doesn’t have to mean that your internal IT team is locked out of your systems. Search for providers that offer co-managed solutions that provide ongoing support while still allowing your staff access to critical system information.
5. Know When Broader Managed Services Make Sense
For some financial institutions, targeted support may be enough. But when gaps start to span multiple areas, a broader managed model may be easier to sustain.
CSI’s 2026 Spending Outlook found that 74% of financial institution leaders prefer to consolidate technology with as few providers as possible.
If gaps stretch across infrastructure, cybersecurity, support, and governance, a broader managed model may provide a more streamlined approach with greater consistency and accountability. It can also give smaller teams access to specialized expertise and added capacity without hiring for every role.
Build an IT Model That Can Change with Your Institution
Managed IT doesn’t have to come down to a choice between keeping everything in-house or fully outsourcing it. The right model gives your financial institution the expertise, coverage, and resilience it needs while preserving governance and visibility.
For some institutions, that may mean filling a few targeted gaps. For others, a broader managed services model may make more sense as staffing or risk demands grow. Base your decision on your strategy, risk profile, staffing realities, and the full cost of maintaining those capabilities internally.
About the Author
Sean Martin is the Director of Product Strategy for Managed Services at CSI and has worked to establish cybersecurity programs for financial institutions for over 15 years. Previously, Sean has served as Network and Security Operations Manager, Product Manager, and various engineering roles since 2001.